Brands get political.
But good ethical practice can translate to political provocation.
In recent months, H&M, Nike, Burberry and Adidas have said they will no longer source cotton from China’s Xinjiang region after reports that minority Uighurs were being used as forced labor to pick cotton. China denies this and says cotton production in Xinjiang—which makes up 20% of the world’s supply—is highly mechanized.
The issue exploded last month after Western governments sanctioned key officials in Xinjiang for alleged human rights abuses, triggering a widespread Chinese consumer boycott of Western brands that’s still playing out.
China’s biggest online sellers removed H&M products from their platforms, while ride-hailing apps removed its stores from maps. Six H&M stores in lower-tier cities were swiftly closed by landlords, Bloomberg News reported, from some 550 stores nationwide.
Chinese tech giant Tencent cancelled an upcoming partnership with Burberry on the hit video game Honor of Kings, which has 100 million daily active users.
Meanwhile, Chinese TV stations blurred out Western brand logos on T-shirts and shoes in shows. And more than two dozen Chinese celebrities said they would stop working with Western brands. One, actor-singer Li Yifeng, said he would only cooperate with brands that sourced cotton from Xinjiang.
China’s consumer market
The latest uproar underlines both the growing clout of China’s consumer market, which continues to expand when many others are shrinking, as well as how it can become a weapon in geopolitics.
China surpassed the United States as the world’s biggest fashion market in 2019, according to McKinsey. Bain & Company estimated that China accounted for one-fifth of the world luxury market in 2020, up from 11% in 2019.
“The challenge for foreign brands has always been about how to sell your stuff to China’s 1.4 billion at the same time as satisfying your global customers’ growing demands to get your ethics right,” BBC’s Shanghai correspondent Robin Brant wrote in an analysis of the Xinjiang cotton controversy. “Some see it as simply Sales vs Ethics; they choose which side to come down on. Others try to find a way to achieve both.”
Or, as China’s foreign ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying put it, “Chinese people will not allow some foreigners to eat China’s rice while smashing its bowls.”
H&M reportedly has over 500 stores in China. The Swedish fashion giant issued a statement, without mentioning Xinjiang: “We are working together with our colleagues in China to do everything we can to manage current challenges and find a way forward. China is a very important market to us and our long-term commitment to the country remains strong.”
Brands under pressure
Studies have shown that consumers, especially younger ones, increasingly expect brands to share their values. A Wunderman Thompson Intelligence study last year found that 85% of American gen Zers think brands should be about something more than profit and 80% believe brands should help make people’s lives better.
In the US, Delta Airlines and Coca Cola—two of the largest employers in the state of Georgia—have spoken out against a new state law that restricts voting access, with a disproportionate impact on Black voters. Last week, Will Smith said he would pull production of his $100-million slavery-era thriller Emancipation out of Georgia over the same voting law.
In China, Western brands have made missteps before. In August 2019, Chinese consumers called for boycotts of Versace, Coach, Givenchy, Calvin Klein and Asics after the brands listed their global store locations in a way where Hong Kong and Macau—both special administrative regions in China—appeared as entities separate from China.
Those boycotts were fueled by Chinese nationalist pride at a time when anti-Beijing protests were happening in Hong Kong and the US-China trade war was heating up.
The future of cotton
With the cotton controversy, China is taking a strategic approach beyond boycotts.
It is ramping up its own version of a cotton industry watchdog—Weilai Cotton, or Future Cotton—to counter the Swiss-based Better Cotton Initiative, of which H&M and others are members.
Weilai Cotton will start with recruiting Chinese brands, the South China Morning Post reported. Cotton garments will be tagged with a QR code that shows its supply chain, including the farm of origin, the processing factory and yarn plant and how much fabric was purchased in the same batch.
“We have been living with Switzerland’s standards for years, but the country doesn’t even produce cotton,” Weilai coordinator Zhao Yan was quoted saying by the South China Morning Post. “Now it is time to form our own national standards.”
Main image courtesy of H&M